Marketing Challenges and Opportunities
during Recession
Divya
Singh
Dept. of Management Studies,
IEC Business School, Institutional Area, Knowledge Park I, Greater Noida, India
*Corresponding Author E-mail: ds.chauhan10@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
This
paper examines the marketing challenges and opportunities during recession. In
this research work, the authors have examined in detail the current economic scenarios
both with in the country and outside the country to
trace out the various factors which have overtly and covertly contributed
towards these recessionary trends.
In
light of piquant reality, the focus of the study is to underline the various
pulls and pushes through which the market is undergoing and also to provide
suitable courses through which the business organization should reorient their
marketing operations in particular and business operations in general.
A recession is a cyclical phase when the
nation’s economy is slowing or it is the reduction of the Gross Domestic
Product (GDP) for at least six months. The producers and consumers are the two
basic people upon whom the whole economy revolves. The value of goods and
services is determined by supply and demand. In case the price is too high
there will be less demand and the producer reduces the price to increase
supply.
Increasing
demand leads to an increase in the production thereby increased supply which in
turn results in increased labor, materials and overall increase in price. Now
the general feeling is good. You want to make investments and consequently the
stock markets go up.
Consequently this leads to overproduction
and the supply exceeds consumption. Now the attitude of the people changes to
saving mentality and this can lead to a contracting economy. People spotting a
negative trend on one area fear the same to happen in other areas and suddenly
recession is on.
At a glance, in a market economy the market
is determined by demand and competition putting it beyond any control. A
government has the fiscal and monetary policies in controlling the recession.
While the former is on collecting and spending money and latter on manipulating
the available money. Both can either improve the situation or worsen it.
INTRODUCTION:
The signs of an imminent recession
are
all around us. The spillover from the supreme mortgage
crisis
is weakening both consumer confidence and the consumer spending–much of it on
credit–that has been buoying the US economy.
Companies should bear eight
factors in mind when making their marketing plans for 2008 and 2009:
Instead of cutting the market
research budget, you need to know more than ever how consumers are
redefining value
and
responding to the recession. Price elasticity curves are changing. Consumers
take more time searching for durable goods and negotiate harder at the point of
sale. They are more willing to postpone purchases, trade down, or buy less.
Must-have features of yesterday are today’s can-live-withouts.
Trusted brands are especially valued and they can still launch new products
successfully but interest in new brands and new categories fades. Conspicuous
consumption becomes less prevalent.
When economic hard times loom,
we tend to retreat to our village. Look for cozy hearth-and-home family scenes
in advertising to replace images of extreme sports, adventure and rugged
individualism. Zany humor and appeals on the basis of fear are out. Greeting
card sales, telephone use and discretionary spending on home furnishings and
home entertainment will hold up well, as uncertainty prompts us to stay at home
but also stay connected with family and friends.
This is not the time to cut
advertising. It is well documented that brands that increase advertising during
a recession, when competitors are cutting back, can improve market share and
return on investment at lower cost than during good economic times. Uncertain
consumers need the reassurance of known brands–and more consumers at home
watching television can deliver higher than expected audiences at lower
cost-per-thousand impressions.
Brands with deep pockets may be
able to negotiate favorable advertising rates and lock them in for several
years. If you have to cut marketing spending, try to maintain the frequency of
advertisements by shifting from 30-to-15 second advertisements, substituting
radio for television advertising, or increasing the use of direct marketing,
which gives more immediate sales impact.
Marketers must reforecast demand
for each item in their product lines as consumer’s trade down to models that
stress good value, such as cars with fewer options. Tough times favor
multi-purpose goods over specialized products and weaker items in product lines
should be pruned.
In grocery-products categories,
good-quality own-brands gain at the expense of national brands. Industrial
customers prefer to see products and services unbundled and priced separately.
Gimmicks are out; reliability, durability, safety and performance are in. New
products, especially those that address the new consumer reality and thereby
put pressure on competitors, should still be introduced but advertising should
stress superior price performance, not corporate image.
In uncertain times, no one wants
to tie up working capital in excess inventories. Early-buy allowances, extended
financing and generous return policies motivate distributors to stock your full
product line. This is particularly true with unproven new products. Be careful
about expanding distribution to lower-priced channels; doing so can jeopardize
existing relationships and your brand image. However, now may be the time to
drop your weaker distributors and upgrade your sales force by recruiting those
sacked by other companies.
Customers will be shopping
around for the best deals. You do not necessarily have to cut list prices but
you may need to offer more temporary price promotions, reduce thresholds for
quantity discounts, extend credit to long-standing customers and price smaller
pack sizes more aggressively. In tough times, price cuts attract more consumer
support than promotions such as sweepstakes and mail-in offers.
In all but a few technology
categories where growth prospects are strong, companies are in a battle for
market share and, in some cases, survival. Knowing your cost structure can
ensure that any cuts or consolidation initiatives will save the most money with
minimum customer impact.
Companies such as Wal-Mart and
Southwest Airlines, with strong positions and the most productive cost
structures in their industries, can expect to gain market share. Other
companies with healthy balance sheets can do so by acquiring weak competitors.
Although most companies are
making employees redundant, chief executives can cement the loyalty of those
who remain by assuring employees that the company has survived difficult times
before, maintaining quality rather than cutting corners and servicing existing
customers rather than trying to be all things to all people. CEOs must spend
more time with customers and employees.
Economic recession can elevate
the importance of the finance director’s balance sheet over the marketing
manager’s income statement. Managing working capital can easily dominate
managing customer relationships. CEOs must counter this. Successful companies
do not abandon their marketing strategies in a recession; they adapt them.
ACT NOW TO BEAT RECESSION:
A financial perspective for
small business survival
Many business cycles are
manifestations of interconnected periods of boom and bust. The boom
characterized by risks, over-optimism and confidence of the past decades has
recently been replaced by fear, diminished expectations and other effects
natural of a recession. Recession is here, and everyone is talking about it, in
offices, the televisions and in networking meetings.
Recession affects small
businesses with low capacity to absorb the effect of cash crunch, the most.
Therefore it is a good time for small businesses to reconsider its financial
situation, take stock of the challenges and opportunities and take the steps
required for facing the long haul ahead. Remember, in a recession or other hard
times, you need to be able to act quickly before it's too late to save the
business.
Here are a few ways to beat recession:
Get the most of your fixed costs - Fixed costs
are also called ‘Sunk Cost', meaning that one has to spend them even if revenue
size has reduced. Look for opportunities to spread fixed costs over more
revenue streams, or look for ways to absorb fixed costs. For example, if the
rent for your office premises is Rs.40, 000, find if you can sublet a part of
the space, say a room, or table spaces to non-complete businesses. If you have
extra telephone lines, look to see if you can surrender a line that has a
higher fixed monthly charge payable to the service provider. Negotiate with
your various service providers to cooperate with you and accept a lowered fee.
It works.
Question every single expense - Its
not likely you'll find one big cut. What's very likely is that you'll find
several smaller cuts that will add up to significant amounts, and every three
rupee you save can be the equivalent of a topline of
ten before tax earnings. You can't save your way to prosperity, but this
exercise will help you find ways to free up operational cash.
Reduce inventory - How much can
you reduce your inventory? Don't carry larger inventories than you need, and
negotiate for just-in-time delivery with your suppliers. If you need to have
stock, try to stock up items that turn quickly, and reduce your holdings in low
demand items.
Be On Top Of Your Cash - Make a projected cash flow
statement for the coming 12 months. Make sure you add all possible expenses,
including drawings, yearly taxes, FBT on expenses, and capital payments. Then
spend only as per projected cash flow. Once you take charge of your cash flow
this way, you will not be left with surprises that may affect the liquidity of
your business.
Use Cash Or Debit Cards - As a business owner, this is
the most trying of times and personal financial discipline will certainly go a
long way to tide the times. Discipline would include reducing unwanted spends.
A simple way of saving cash is to use a debit card or cash when making
purchases.
If you use cash then this will
probably make you think hard about buying things as it will significantly
reduce the cash you have in your cash box.
Hold On To Your Best Employees - In recessionary times, your
best employees have financial problems of their own, and their first priority
is to take care of their families - through a raise from you or through a job
change to one of your competitors. Losing well-trained quality workers is
something that you can ill afford to let happen. Make sure you keep your best
employees through deferred bonus programs - but make sure that they are tied to
performance.
Hype up productivity and
efficiency -
In one company I know of, all staff except mothers with young children have
been asked to put in 20% extra working hours. Increasing working hours
officially has led to the company doing away with recruitment of 10 new
personnel, thereby saving a substantial amount on salaries. The company has
also won the admiration of both team members and public alike with this simple
move to beat recession. Likewise, efficiency can be enhanced using simple tools
like Balanced Scorecards or taking up quality initiatives like quality circles,
six sigma implementations etc.
Avoid falling behind on your
mortgage repayments - Whether its corporate loan or personal loan, it makes sense to
consider making overpayments now - this way you can make underpayments or even
take a payment holiday subsequently if you have a cash crunch later. You could
also re-negotiate the interest on loans should interest rates fall, although
lending banks need not agree to cut their interest rates when RBI reduces the
base rate.
Delayed payment of mortgage
repayments could be negotiated - Contact lenders as soon as you realize
you may have a problem keeping up repayments. You may be able to reach
agreement on freezing interest or paying an affordable amount. If lenders can
see you making an effort to pay at least something, you are much more likely to
get a helpful reaction.
Increase marketing spends - A common mistake that
companies make is cut your marketing budget. However, if ever customer
intelligence was important it's now. The key is to look at your marketing rupee
as an investment not an expense. Use the customer knowledge that you have and
implement smart ways of spending on marketing costs.
Focus on customer delight - With less
money in circulation, focus on revenue. Contemplate smaller jobs that wouldn't
normally excite you. In a slowdown your staff is likely to have less to do.
Keep them busy with whatever business there is. Lose the "OK, we'll even
do this, now" attitude. You'll be competing for those jobs, and the
competition is likely to be stiff.
Outsourcing during recession?
Yes! - The
rules of how business is done are changing. Focus your attention on maximizing
revenue and on leveraging your intellectual capital. How much do you need to be
in control? Think about outsourcing work that doesn't create revenue.
For example, if you have been
spending valuable time overseeing accounting data, you should consider
outsourcing your accounting services to an outsourced partner. Another
possibility is to work with part time college students as interns or trainees
while ensuring the outputs and deliverables are clearly defined for this model
to be successful. Outsourcing also allows you to "demand" output from
the service provider, thereby paying only for the services received.
While fund and
asset related actions can stall the impact of recession considerably, other
ways and means directly related to a safe way of increasing return on
investment and increasing business itself include the following:
1. Look for improved ways
to reach your target market. For example, if your prospects primarily arrive
through your Website, and your traffic is down, you might consider taking some
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) steps to improve your search rankings.
2. As much as we dread any
economic recession, there are economists who insist tough times force us to
become more efficient, and that's a good thing. Perhaps this is most obvious
when it comes to staffing.
3. Seek "Referral
Business" - Contact your customers, family and friends and ask for
referrals. Tell people you need more work. If they believe in your competence,
they'll come through for you. A more proactive method would be to join referral
networking groups, like the BNI. Although it will cost some money, investing
now in focused networks that provide business opportunity will go a long way in
a short span of time.
4. Losing Clients? Focus
on those with you - Service them - With fewer customers you'll be tempted to
reduce the number of customer service personnel. Many of your competitors will.
Don't do it. Of course now is the time to cut expenses, but not in ways that
touch the customer.
5. Listen! Listening can
create a world - Listen to what your customers are telling you. Watch how
they're behaving. Consider what it feels like to be your customer in this
economy. What would you do in their situation? Now, help them to do it.
6. Change perceptions for
a healthy business - and planet - The current perception in the business community
is that addressing sustainability is a cost bringing no return; and that’s
where issues are framed in terms of moral values and reputation, you can't show
real ROI. With fears of an even deeper economic downturn, everyone is looking
to their bottom line.
However, Corporate India and
companies abroad have consistently demonstrated that companies with corporate
social responsibilities have done well even in times of recession. Integrating
sustainability across your business processes can bring real returns to
business profitability, because eco-efficiency gains go straight to your bottom
line. A lean, green business is a healthy business both for profit and planet.
The message is - spend on
sustainable model of running business and indulge in activities that engage the
employees and stakeholders in conserving the green on earth. Maybe take up tree
planting.
By using the above methods, you can not
only survive the recessionary phase in your small business, but thrive once it
passes.
If an economy has slowed down and market
trends show a negative trend, you need not bother. You should have the ability
to manage during this tough period. Most of the companies manage by being
selective and focused as far as the choice of products is concerned. During this
period, an entrepreneur always thinks of cost reduction by a proper allocation
of resources and consolidation of businesses.
The IT companies like TCS, Infosys, Wipro, Satyam and
HCL, all have remained in the top class of service providers even during the
period of recession:
Without bringing down your product quality and
reduction in the marked prices, you need to sell your products in the market.
For this you need to devise suitable strategies so that your business is
not affected by the recession.
These are some of the basic steps to manage your
business during economic upheaval:
·
Monitor
your cash flow: Try to
convert all your inventories into cash so that you are saved from the bad sale
period. Stock less products as compared to your previous stocks. At the same
time control your expenses and increase your liquid funds.
·
Offer
Discounts and Credits: You
can consider offering your products on credit to the final supplier and to your
customer too. By offering discounts on your products you can increase your
chances of sale.
·
Ask
your supplier to give the raw materials/products on credit: You can always request your supplier to give
products on credit for a time period till the recession phase is over.
·
Keep
in constant touch with your customers: If you have been maintaining a list of loyal
customers, you should not forget them. Pacify them by all means. Also ask them
to recommend your name to their close friends or relatives.
·
Spend
less on the publicity: During this period you can cut down your
expenditure on miscellaneous activities like promotional events and marketing
campaigns to publicize your product. You just can not
shun this activity as this is vital to boost up your sales process, so choose
advertising options which offers you discounted package.
·
Increase
your portfolio of products: For example, you can expand your product line by introducing a new
product. But, keep it at a high price and exclusively targeted towards premium
customers.
During the time of slowdown in economy, the nation
is in deficit of revenues, so you can think of pushing your business across the
boundaries like consider exporting the products on a global level. Often the
companies take up offshore business in such a crisis. Always try to maintain a
good relationship with employees as well as vendors and customers.
REWRITE YOUR MARKETING PLAN FOR 2009-10:
Are we in a recession? No. Will there be a
recession in 2009? Probably not. But India's corporate optimism has started to
sink on worries about the global economic downturn, high cost of credit,
reduced availability of funds, weakening demand and exports slump. So, let us
assume that our economy will be in a recession in 2009-10 and that as marketers
we need to work within that reality.
When it comes to SMEs (Small and Medium
Businesses), the relationship between economic environment and business
strategy is very significant since even some small changes in the economic
environment or market tend to have far-reaching effects upon these businesses.
So, what should our SMEs (Small and Medium
Businesses) do in this scenario? Smart athletes often choose to increase
their pace on hills; it is when they sense the existence of a great opportunity
in the form of fatigued opponents. The same can be said of smart businesses
when they enter a recessionary phase of economy. A recession is the best time
for businesses to start their marketing efforts afresh.
So, a recession requires SMEs to modify
their marketing strategies. But how? Let's discuss some smart marketing ideas
that can make your business recession proof-
1. Market research: When there is an economic slowdown or a
recession, consumers start redefining value: they value their every rupee, ask
themselves how much they will benefit by purchasing a certain product or
service, negotiate harder than ever before, buy less or postpone purchases.
They tend to look for trusted brands while
interest in new brands fades. To face such challenges successfully, SMEs need
to know more about their consumers and how they are redefining value during a recessionary
phase of economy. So, it is not the right time for SMEs to cut their market
research budget during a recession. Instead you should double the budget,
analysis the changing trends carefully, and change your marketing strategies
accordingly. (Also read our story: Marketing research: A must for
businesses)
2. Analysis market segments: In a recessionary phase of economy, not all
business segments suffer equally; some suffer more, some less, some not at all.
In the current economic slowdown in India, for example, only a few business
segments like textiles, housing & real estate, and especially the export
based businesses have been worst hit while some other segments have not been
feeling the downturn so much acutely.
To grab opportunity during a recession, a
business must find out and understand the market segments which are least hit
or less prone to an economic crunch. There may be enough opportunities in some
segments which are till now only the secondary focus of your business.
3. Emphasize on advertising: In a study of the the
1981-82 recession in the United States, McGraw Hill Research analyzed 600 B2B
companies in 16 different industries. The results revealed that companies which
maintained or increased their advertising expenditures during the period
averaged significantly higher sales growth not only during the recession period
but even for the following three years.
Several other researches reveal that
businesses that continue their advertising and promotional campaigns during
hard economic times perform better. When competitors are cutting back on
advertising, increasing advertising during a recession can improve market share
and return on investment to a significant level and that too at comparatively
lower cost. (Also read our stories: Ride the storm in a downturn; recession
proof your business, beat the downturn)
4. Pricing: When you offer your products or services at some
'great' reduced prices all of a sudden, it is most likely that your sales will
soar as an immediate effect. But it is not a very good idea, especially for a
SME with a small budget. Instead, SMEs should consider adding more value to
your customers and launching some temporary price reduction strategies such as
offering quantity discounts, extend credit to long-standing customers, etc.
But again you should be cautious in
implementing this type of strategies as it might make customer think later (one
day the recession will be over) that your products or services are overpriced.
5. Increase market share: How can SMEs transform an economic slowdown
into a great opportunity? Just by increasing their market share. As the
competitors are cowering down and waiting the storm out, now is the time for
businesses to increase their market share. However, it is not always possible for
SMEs to invest or go for acquisitions in turbulent times.
But they can make the best of their customer
base selling more to existing customers and increasing their average spends. It
is also important to maintain the quality of your products or services during a
slowdown period even though sales fall off. (Also read our story: Increase your
market share to break the back of the beast)
6. Reorganize product portfolio: What sells during an economic crunch?
Historically, sales of luxury goods are suffered while sales of basic goods
remain unaffected. Although it is partially true, businesses need to realize
that there are some other crucial factors which need to be considered carefully
while preparing their marketing strategy for a recessionary period of economy.
During a recession, people prefer cost
effective products to costly solutions; multipurpose products to specialized
goods, separately priced unbundled products to costly bundled packages. Also
remember that innovative products can play a very crucial role in translating
the moments of uncertainty into moments of glory.
7. Spend smart: Needless to say, when you have less pennies
in your pocket, it is most important to review your expenses. During an
economic slowdown, a business must carefully identify which marketing costs are
yielding improvements to their profitability and market share and which are
not. When a recession strikes many businesses cut their budgets and people in
marketing disproportionately and neglect some crucial marketing strategies such
as advertising, branding, targeted communications, etc.
It is a self destructive measure for
businesses, especially for SMEs as they are usually equipped with limited
resources and manpower.
History is the witness to testify that
businesses which enter a recession with a pre-established strategic emphasis on
marketing are well positioned to boost their competitive advantage. A recession
is a labyrinth of both crisis and opportunities, and the winners will be those
who put their thinking cap better. We do not know exactly what awaits our SMEs
just yet. The current slowdown in Indian economy might or might not usher in a
recession in the coming days of 2009. But our SMEs should prepare for the
worst.
The global recession has meant that
large corporate worldwide are downsizing their staff, production and expenses.
Even some of India's biggest companies have laid off several employees and
might continue doing so in the coming months.
Agreed the economy is in bad shape.
But remember great opportunities exist even if an economy is in bad shape.
It is those who capitalize on these opportunities and sustain themselves even
through tough times who will rule the economy in the coming years.
Folks looking to start a new business,
Indian startups, small and medium enterprises, SMEs, need to look at the market
in a positive way and find their way towards a great future. Young
entrepreneurs, start-ups as well as employees who have got laid off, should
consider recession as nature's plan to bring fresh perspective and new
motivation to the world. Future leaders are current individuals who believe in
change, globalization, new strategies and innovations.
THE TRICK TO SURVIVE IS...
The problem we all face is that, when the
economy is making very fast progress, the basics are forgotten. When it is
the recession, it is about getting back to the basics.
1. Serving the basic needs
Imagine every individual has some basic
needs like food, shelter, clothes, healthcare, travel, electricity and water.
When market is cutting down their spending, basic spending is always going to
stay the same; it just needs more cost effective solutions.
Hence the opportunities coming out of the
recession shall be: cheaper food, cost effective housing, and cheaper clothes,
cheaper travel and so on...
2. Using technology to scale
Technology is the way to scale. It is the
technology that enables us to keep in touch with our friends. It is technology
that lets us connect to millions of individuals, know and share information
that would otherwise take years to reach -- with the cost that every common
person can afford. Businesses not just need to consume technology, but also use
it to reach broader audience.
3. Staying global, thinking local
Recession puts business models at test.
Recession is going to demand reaching maximum audience for the same investment
in production happening in the local market. Anywhere in the world, basic needs
of people remain the same. The trick is serving global audience with the
product designed for local audience.
4. Cost control with bootstrapping
Venture capital is going to be hard to find,
one needs to bootstrap the business with very less resources and still be able
to provide the best service quality.
5. Less liability, more utilization
Trick will be to lessen the fixed costs of
the business, so even if the sales get affected for some time, it does not put
burden on the company's accounts.
CONCLUSION:
While the optimism over India’s growth story
may be tempered because of the global economic slowdown, India is still growing
and is considered a rising country in the world. India is not in recession but
has been badly hit by the global slowdown and the crisis in different sectors.
Till the economic slowdown hit the world and
before the Satyam Computer episode broke out, India and China were expected to
beat the rest of the world in economic growth.
The high economic growth rate, the
tremendous development in IT and engineering in various fields, a young
population, the feeling that we are the world champions in cricket in 2010 and
“in everything else in the conceivable future” — that optimism, that hype, has
been tempered recently but still we are growing and considered a rising country
in the world.
We are “not in a recession” and Mr. P.
Chidambaram, currently Home Minister and earlier Finance Minister, had reminded
us “India is by no means in a recession”. But India has been badly hit by the
global slowdown and by the crisis in different sectors everywhere in the
country. Its effect could be felt in metros and large cities and perhaps less
so in small towns but its effect will be there as well.
Jobs have been lost, demands have
diminished, credit has been choked in many areas and even good enterprises
lacked credit support from banks. Despite this overall picture, India would
still be growing at something like 6 per cent plus. But the environment, the
context is very challenging today, which is a good time to reflect on change.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
AND REFERENCES:
1.
‘‘International Trade and Economic Growth” by Hendrik Van den Berg & Joshua J. Lewer
2.
Macro Economics, Theory and Applications by GS Gupta
3.
Macro Economics, by Rudiger
Dornbusch, Stanley Fischer & Richard Chartz
JOURNALS:
1.
European journal of law in Economics
2.
Journal of Economic inequality
3.
Journal of cultural economics
WEBSITES:
3.
ibnlive.in.com
Received on 30.04.2010 Accepted on 10.05.2010
©A&V
Publications all right reserved
Asian J. Management 1(1): Jan. – Mar. 2010 page 08-13