NKC
and Knowledge Grid among University Libraries of Chhattisgarh
Dr. Mohammed Imtiaz
Ahmed*
Assistant Librarian at
*Corresponding Author E-mail: imtiazexplores@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Management Information Systems are tools designed to
improve management decisions. A changing user population, technology
enhancement transformation of scholarly communication system, digital
libraries, new approaches to management, renewed commitment to planning and
assessment, financial constraints, declining budget, information gluts,
constant change in IT ,web services, reader’s expectations for 24 x 7 services,
time shortage etc are compelling MIS to be mandatory in libraries. The present
Study offers measures to library effectiveness and automation, offers tools for
better reader services through integrated and collaborative working of
neighboring libraries, and projects Management Information System as the tool
for realizing expectations from libraries of modern world.
As per guidelines of National Knowledge Commission
Report 2009, UGC and NAAC recommendations, creation of Knowledge Grid and
resource sharing among university libraries of Chhattisgarh has been suggested.
Present status of MIS in 8 University Libraries of Chhattisgarh has been
studied and model has been proposed for MIS and resource sharing among them.
Impact of IT on libraries, exponential growth of information, applications of
MIS in libraries, and its significance and performance measurement has been
elaborated. A Software has been designed
that enables MIS through integrated database.
KEYWORDS – MIS, performance measurements, resource sharing,
University Libraries, knowledge grid and NKC.
Libraries are the carriers of civilization.
Without books, history is silent, literature dumb, science crippled, thought
and speculation at a standstill. Without libraries, the development of
civilization would have been impossible; they are the engines of change.
National Knowledge
Commission Report (2006-2009) has very clearly mentioned that Academic
libraries play a pivotal role in dissemination of knowledge and are an extremely
important element of the foundation of a knowledge economy. There is widespread
agreement that there is an urgent need for reform in the Libraries and
Information Service (LIS) sector. Several initiatives in this regard have
already been taken by the Government. NKC has consulted extensively with
diverse stakeholders including a Working Group of experts and professionals.
NKC’s recommendations for formulating strategies in the LIS sector are as
follows:
Libraries should
be so organized and the staff so trained that they become relevant to user
communities (including special groups) in every respect. Also, to optimize
resources, efforts should be made to synergize the strengths of different types
of libraries through innovative collaboration. NKC proposes the creation of a
model Library Charter, a list of services to be performed by libraries, a
Library Network and a National Repository for Bibliographic Records.
NKC also
recommends that the catalogues of all libraries should be put on local state
and national website with necessary linkages. This will enable networking of
different types of libraries and setting up of a National Repository of
Bibliographic Records and a centralized collaborative virtual enquiry-handling
system using the latest ICT. To enable equitable and universal access to
knowledge resources, libraries should be encouraged to create more digital
resources by digital resources by digitizing relevant reading material in
different languages, which can be shared at all levels. Peer-reviewed research
papers resulting from publicly funded research should also be made available through
open access channels, subject to copyright regulations. It is recommended that
open standards and free and open source software may be used for the above.
Indian Higher Education System comprises of
116.12 Lakh students, 431 universities and 5.05 Lakh Teachers. However, census 2001 confirms a Gross
Enrollment Ratio of merely 13.6% in higher education, (gross enrollment ratio (GER) is a ratio of total students enrolled out
of the total population in 18 to 23 years of age group).
The present study measures effectiveness of
libraries for their services to readers (the 13.6% of population as GER) and
offers solutions for capacity enhancement to extend their reach to non readers
(remaining 86.4% beyond GER). There is
widespread agreement that there is an urgent need for reform in the Libraries
and Information Service (LIS) sector.
Living in an age of information explosion it is
estimated that the amount of information in the world doubles every 20 months. Libraries, as centres of
learning are experiencing unprecedented rates of change, both internally and
from external sources (Brophy and Couling,
1996). A changing user population, technology enhancement,
transformation of the scholarly communication system, digital libraries, new
approaches to planning and assessment throughout the library are propelling the
new environment.
We find that global changes through the information and communication technologies
(ICT), have had an impact on the functioning of academic libraries. Integrated library system, or ILS,
is another enterprise resource planning system for a library. One word, ‘INTERNET’ has completely changed the
way Libraries operate. Today's libraries are having a paradigm shift towards
web-based e-resources. The conventional bibliographic resources are now fast
supplemented by the e-resources. It is huge task for librarians to maintain a
supply chain that moves shoulder to shoulder with a global information
generation rate that doubles at every 20 months.
Management Information Systems (MIS) have emerged
as a solution to this capacity expansion requirement of Academic Libraries.
According to McClure (1990), Management information systems are tools designed
to improve management
decisions. Library Automation
stands as a major prerequisite for the Management Information System. The
present study aims to focus on Library Automation status for successful
implementation of MIS.
In the present day, the MIS based libraries
maintain customer (reader) focus as their central idea during all
performances. The objective of an MIS
based Library is to be an effective library through:
(1) Providing convenience and justice to its readers.
(2) Attract
non-readers to become readers.
Maintaining laws of
Library Science in letter and spirit allows us to further the scope of our
performance to be extended through integration with all neighbouring libraries
through resource sharing that again provides achievement of aforesaid library
objectives of convenience and justice to readers, and, attracting non-readers
to become readers.
METHODOLOGY
AND OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY:
Taking into consideration the
recommendations of the National Knowledge Commission, the present study is
therefore an attempt to propose collaborative
partnership with neighboring university libraries of Chhattisgarh in
order to make better use of common resources and to improve services to
Readers. The Study offers software as
the tool to enable such collaborative working. However offering any tool to
facilitate Library operations shall be incomplete until it bears a strong
Customer focus.
It was also decided to conduct a survey of
readers (Teachers and Students) on Library Automation and Library Effectiveness
at eight University Libraries of Chattisgarh namely Pandit Ravishankar Shukla University, Guru
Ghasidas University, Indira
Gandhi Krishi Vishwavidyalaya,
Indira Kala Sangeet Vishwavidyalaya, Hidayatullah
National Law University, Chhattisgarh Swami Vivekanand
Technical University, Pandit Sundarlal
Sharma (Open) University and, Kushabhau Thakre Patrakarita Avam Jansanchar Vishwavidyalaya.
Automation
is a state of replacing the human performance of activities with mechanical or
electronic processes. Library Automation is a process of adding electronic
resources to its bibliographic resources and replacing its human performances
with electronic processes.
Effectiveness
is a state of accomplishment of a predefined purpose or producing the intended
or expected result. ‘Library Effectiveness’ is a continuous process of
facilitating its readers with desired bibliographic and web graphic resources
at lowest cost and time.
It
was thus hypothesised, firstly, that “Libraries with
higher automation level will show more effectiveness than libraries with lower
level of automation”.
Secondly,
that, “Teachers will perceive higher library effectiveness compared to
Students”.
SUBJECTS
The present study collected responses of 240
readers including Teachers and Students of eight university libraries of
Chhattisgarh
The respondents were asked about their
perceptions on Automation Level and resulting Effectiveness of their University
Library. The sample distribution of the present study was summarized.
The present research was conducted by using
the three-way ANOVA (analysis of variance) technique with the 3 x 2 x 8
factorial design revealing the three independent variables as three levels of
Library Automation as high, moderate and low; two types of Readers as Teachers
and Students; and eight University Libraries as PRSU, GGU, IGKV, IKSV, HNLU, CSVTU, PSOU and KBTV.
Library Effectiveness was the sole dependent variable of this study.
The combined effect of these three
independent variables i.e. effect of various levels of ‘Library Automation’ in
all eight ‘University Libraries’ on both ‘Types of Readers’ (Teachers and
Students)] were studied for the resulting ‘Library Effectiveness’.
Two scales ‘LAS’ (Library Automation Scale)
and ‘LES’ (Library Effectiveness Scale) were used in the present study.
The first scale ‘LAS’ carried fifteen items
measuring the four factors as “Commitment, Infrastructure, Services and Staff
Training”.
The second scale, ‘Library Effectiveness
Scale’ (LES) was specifically constructed for the present study.
In the present study, Library Effectiveness
is measured through factors of Library Performance, Reader’s Satisfaction, and
Staff’s Competence. ‘LES’ carried fifty five items measuring the aforesaid
three factors.
METHODOLOGY
The present study intended to investigate about Library
Effectiveness by maintaining higher Automation Level in the University
Libraries of Chhattisgarh. Using
appropriate statistical tables, common reference of F-ratio was applied to test
the significance of differences for verification of various hypotheses. On
prima-facie the assumptions for applying F-test i.e. normalcy and homogeneity
of data were tested.
The study further used a three-dimensional
(3 x 2 x 8) ANOVA technique at SPSS to analyze the data.
PROCEDURE
Once the two scales were constructed, a
total of 240 Readers (Teachers and Students) from all eight University
Libraries of Chhattisgarh were asked to respond on the given scales. The
collection of responses was then followed by scoring and compilation of data.
Finally the SPSS software was used for application of statistical tools and
tables for the purpose of data analysis.
LIBRARY
EFFECTIVENESS TOOLS
The present study therefore offers software
as a tool that fulfills all requirements of an effective library as addressed
under all dimensions of the LAS and LES. Through the use of integrated
database, the proposed MIS based software provides solution to all limitations
of the conventional library management systems. The integrated database
comprises Membership Data, Bibliographic Data, Circulation Data and the
Maintenance Data.
For the Bibliographic data, 13 resource
types were identified as Books, Serials, Theses, Textual Data, Reports,
Meetings, Special Edition, News Papers, Patents, Standards, Annual Reviews,
Irregular Serials, and Monographic Serials.
For the Membership data, members were
classified in two categories: Institutional Members and Individual Members. The
Individual Members were further sub divided in two categories as Direct Members
and Indirect Members.
·
Entitlements
for all members can be defined in the type and number of bibliographic
resources to be issued at a time and for the duration for which it can be
issued.
·
For the
Circulation function, the Issue, Re-Issue and Return of all bibliographic
resources are enabled with a cross reference of the integrated database having
predefined Bibliographic and Membership records.
·
The
proposed MIS based software also features the Library Maintenance assistance
through records and automatically generated reminders as per predefined
schedules of physical verification, Shelf Rectification, Dusting and
Preservation of Bibliographic resources. Finally the software shall also
generate various reports as and when required to facilitate routine and policy
decisions of library administration.
With the installation of the proposed software,
no doubt, library effectiveness shall improve. However, continuous improvement
still remains the key. The proposed study therefore provides with the “Library
Audit Checklist”, which makes library performance measurable in terms of
Budgetary Allocation, Cost Effectiveness, Income Substitution, Staffing,
Training, Services, Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE), Readership and
Circulation, Maintenance, and Continuous Improvement.
Information
Technology and its impact on libraries
The Internet
has had a profound impact on society in general and on the field of library and
information science in particular.Information Technologies through Internet has had a
vital impact on academic scenario. The avenues for exploitation of Internet by
library and information centres (LandICs) are
unlimited and endless. Internet provides access to a variety of commercial and
non-commercial information sources which include: bibliographic and full-text
databases; and table of contents.
Advances
in Information Technology of primary journals; electronic and online journals,
books and newsletters; almost all OPACs, graphics databases, multimedia walk
through programs, audio clip art databases; e-mail, directories, product and
library catalogues, campus information systems, etc. Internet is also a test
bed for electronic document delivery, electronic publishing, publicity and
marketing of products and services, and integrated access to local and external
information.
E-resources
and the revolution of IT in academics, in addition to the bibliographic
resources have brought the literature to the researchers on their mouse clicks.
The uses, impact and implications of electronic publishing and online journals
on libraries and information centres has been discussed by various scientists.
Services like ‘Uncover’ of Blackwell and
‘Contents First’ of OCLC offers Internet access to table of contents of several
thousand journals, followed by online ordering of papers. Major publishers like
American Chemical Society and Elsevier are offering their journals on Internet
and OCLC. Many libraries maintain an online catalogue of their publications
over Internet/WWW which could be searched using navigational tools.
McGraw-Hill
is offering electronic version of its Business Week on America Online
which has resulted in attracting new readers. It receives over half a million
clicks on its pages every week and each ‘click’ generates revenue. This
‘feedback’ enabled editors to analyse and feel the pulse of the readers’
interest to revise content Penthouse magazine of USA on Internet attracts about
2 million ‘hits’ daily, a record on Web. Now there are over 400 daily
newspapers, 800 magazines, 1500 newsletters and other products are available,
online via communication networks and the Internet.
The
‘Internet fever’ is slowly spreading in India also. One major development is
the establishment of metropolitan library networks like DELNET, CALIBNET,
ADINET, etc.; the national bibliographic information networks like INFLIBNET,
BTIS, NICNET and the establishment of computer communications networks like
ERNET, NICMAIL/RENNIC which can also be used for transmission of bibliographic
information. The Internet is changing the notion of library from a walled place
into a virtual library,
Information
Explosion and its Management
"In Library and Information Science,
information explosion is a term used for the ever increasing rate of
publication" (Wikipedia, 2005). Information
explosion is a term that describes the rapidly increasing amount of published
information and the effects of this abundance of data. As the amount of
available data grows, the problem of managing the information becomes more
difficult, which can lead to information overload.
The idea of "Information Overload"
has been discussed for decades, but never before has it seemed so relevant.
According to market research firm IDC, by 2011 the digital universe will be 10
times the size it was in 2006. IDC forecasted that the amount of digital
information we generate will exceed our ability to store it this year. This
situation is despite amazing improvements (greater than 100% per year
currently) in disk density and capacity over the last 50 years.
Over
the last 50 years, the computer and communications revolution has changed
radically the way many organizations do their business. According to Charles Jonscher (2000), we are now living in a wired world.
Information is growing exponentially. For instance let
us take the examples of “Chemical Abstracts” and “Mathematical Reviews”. During
1995, 5,62,955 Papers and 3,620 Books were abstracted which were published in
total 1,55,910 pages in Chemical abstracts. But, during 2007, it increased to
8,16,778 Papers and 4,526 Books abstracts published in total 3,91,079 pages.
Chemical abstracts publication record
1907-2007.
|
Year |
Papers |
Books |
Total Abstracts |
Total Pages
Published |
|
1907 |
7994 |
0 |
11847 |
3437 |
|
1927 |
25037 |
582 |
33491 |
5511 |
|
1947 |
30461 |
902 |
39288 |
5547 |
|
1967 |
202684 |
3046 |
242527 |
39521 |
|
1987 |
386466 |
4493 |
476178 |
95187 |
|
2007 |
816778 |
4526 |
1086941 |
391079 |
Digital futures are considered to be the new
answer for the information age. Computers and access to the internet and local
resources, together with generic computing applications, have enabled the user to
access the library from anywhere in the world.
It is our belief that in this world of speed and
continuous momentum, libraries and librarians can come into their own to create
some order and some important signposts. The digital library is an important
component for capturing the explicit knowledge. The 21st century is about the
management of all knowledge and information we have generated and the value
addition we bring to it.
The management of information in the 21st century is
beyond the capacity of a single individual. The amount of information that we
have around is overwhelming. The management of information therefore must move
out of the realm of the individual and shift into the realm of networked
groups.
The eight University libraries may consider creating
Chhattisgarh Virtual University Library GRID by networking the Universities
from Chhattisgarh. India is now in the process of creating virtual universities
and institutions for knowledge sharing, knowledge dissemination and knowledge
reuse.
The world is moving towards internet 2 applications.
Internet 2 applications require advanced networks. That is, these applications
will not run across commercial Internet connections. Internet2 applications
require enhanced networking functionality, such as high bandwidth, low latency
(delay), or multicast not available on our commercial Internet connections.
Internet2 is about everything we do in higher education.
India has established the Information GRID.
ERNET is the Educational and Research Network of India connecting 1500
institutions for internet and intra connectivity for email and other
collaboration.
Management
Information Systems in Libraries
The contemporary approach
casts academic librarians as managers within the higher education system. What
academic librarians need, now much more than ever before, is the information
which will allow them to plan properly, to know whether or not the library
service is meeting the needs of the academic community.
The introduction of
computers into academic libraries was largely a response to the problem of
dealing with increased workloads with fewer staff, and they are now able easily
to handle most of the routine and repetitive work of the library staff. In
addition, they have the capability to enhance the provision of management
information, since automated data processing is able to present reports more
accurately and much faster than manual systems.
Nonetheless, most
librarians claim that they would now like to install decision support systems,
even though they see the expense as a problem. Living in an age of such
information explosion, Management Information Systems (MIS) have emerged as a
solution to this capacity expansion requirement of Academic Libraries.
The MIS's function is to
provide library Staff and Readers with data, information, analysis and tools
that enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of library services and assist in
the decision - making process.
The objectives of an MIS are to assist staff
with the daily decision making process, to maintain better accountability and
control of resources, to monitor budget allocations, to improve overall library
effectiveness by focusing on outcomes to generate internal and external reports
to improve long-term planning and to facilitate performance measures
activities. Further, the MIS intervention offers utility to Readers too by
means of a wider bibliographic database through e-resources.
The present study is therefore an attempt to
propose collaborative partnership with neighboring university libraries of
Chhattisgarh in order to make better use of common resources and to improve
services to Readers.
A management information system (MIS) is a subset of the
overall internal controls covering the application of people, documents,
technologies, and procedures. According to McClure (1990), Management
information systems are tools designed to improve management decisions.The terms MIS and information system are
often confused. Information systems include systems that are not intended for
decision making. The expansionary momentum of the 1960s and
1970s was followed by pressure for efficiency and economies. The 1980s was not
a period in which academic libraries prospered.
The four main objectives
for Management Information systems have been defined as: (1) to facilitate the
decision making process in the library by providing the managers with accurate,
timely, and selective information that assists them in determining a specific
course of action. (2) to provide for the objective performance measurement and
assessment of selected relevant areas of the library. The areas are to be
determined during strategic planning. (3) to provide pertinent information
about the library's internal and external environment and, (4) to provide
information on alternative strategies and contingency plans.
In recent years, data
processing for management information systems in business and industry has
increasingly been undertaken by computers. In
libraries, in contrast, the development of the use of computer has been
modular, in the sense that it is based on a single library operation such as
acquisitions, serials, control or cataloguing. The more general applications of
management information lay hidden, as it is often seen only as a departmental
resource. Technological changes have helped to ease
this problem. As opposed to the use of mainframe and mini-computers, the advent
of the microcomputer now provides an alternative to the dependence on
large-scale centralized computer systems.
Data
Analysis and Interpretation
The present study is intended to investigate
about Library Effectiveness by maintaining Library Automation in the University
Libraries of Chhattisgarh. Using appropriate
statistical tables, common reference of F-ratio was applied to test the
significance of differences for verification of various hypotheses. Scores for
all the scales collected from all the samples were analyzed separately.
The study further uses a three-dimensional
(3 x 2 x 8) ANOVA technique at SPSS to analyze the data whereby numerical
values were assigned for various independent variables of the study. Three
levels of Library Automations were studied as low, moderate and high
respectively. For the dimension of Readers, the two categories were Teachers
and Students respectively. For the dimension of Universities, the eight
University Libraries of Chhattisgarh were studied.
Finally, Library Effectiveness was observed
as the dependent variable.
For the first problem, results reveal the
overall mean score of 129.62 making a favorable indication that Library
Automations positively effects the Library Effectiveness perception of Readers.
Further, for the effects of various levels of Library Automations on Library
Effectiveness, the mean scores of 66.89, 130.33 and 191.64 respectively at the
low, moderate and higher levels of Library Automation make it clearly evident
that higher the Library Automation more will be the Library Effectiveness
perception of the Readers.
For the second problem, the respective mean
scores of Teachers and Students as 148.36 and 110.87 proved that the Teachers
of all libraries perceived their library as more effective compared to their
students.
Significant
main effect value (F = 20.148, p=.000) was found thus there remained no two
ways to accept the first hypothesis that Library Automations strongly affect
the Library Effectiveness.
Significant
main effect value (F = 16.52, p=.001) exhibited that there are significant
differences between perceptions of Teachers and Students for the overall
Library Effectiveness perceptions higher Library Automations in their
University Library.
The
third main effect, ‘Libraries’ i.e. the eight University Libraries of Chhattisgarh,
studies the different levels of Automation in subjected Libraries and its
effect on the perception of the Readers over its Effectiveness state. According
to the study, again the significant main effect value (F = 24.15, p=.0001),
indicated that the Libraries in the present study vary with their levels of
Automation and resulting in a varying reader perception over their
Effectiveness status.
All three
first-order interactions were found to have significant results. Significant
results as (F = 19.74, p =.000) for Level of Library
Automation and Reader; (F = 19.21, p =.001) for Level of Library Automation and Libraries; (F = 27.168, p =.002)
for Readers and Libraries.
Pandit Ravishankar Shukla University
Library scored highest at all levels, followed by Guru Ghasidas
University, Indira Gandhi Krishi
Vishwavidyalaya, Indira
Kala Sangeet Vishwavidyalaya,
Hidayatullah National Law University, Chhattisgarh
Swami Vivekanand Technical University, Pandit Sundarlal Sharma (Open)
University and lastly Kushabhau Thakre
Patrakarita Avam Jansanchar Vishwavidyalaya.
The second-order interaction giving the
combined effect of Level of
Library Automation, Readers and,
Libraries with the dependent variable Library Effectiveness were also studied. Significant F-value
for this second-order interaction (F = 14.114, p=.000) was obtained for this
joint interaction indicating a significant interaction of all the independent
variables together with the dependent variable ‘Library Effectiveness’
The fact that some libraries claimed to have
only 'informal' or 'partial' management information systems or to have no
management information systems does not mean that they had no collection of
external and internal data. They do collect and use information for
establishing library objectives and priorities or for resources allocation, but
they have not formalized their management information systems, typically
because their institutions had not required them to do so. Organizational
commitment therefore stands as major prerequisite for successful implementation
of MIS in university libraries.
CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION:
It is now an
established fact that MIS in library and information sciences through
automation has become inevitable. The environments in which libraries operate are under the constant
pressure of change. Libraries have to create environments that enable
successful assessment and the implementation of results based on these
assessments. Considering the above requirements, the
present study attempted to make the library operations measurable, improvable
and thus effective. The survey of readers on Library Automation and Library
Effectiveness provided feedback on their perceptions and expectations. Among
the major findings of the present study the results for the first hypothesis
that “libraries with higher automation level will show more effectiveness than
libraries with lower level of automation”, revealed that maintaining Library
Automation significantly influenced the overall Library Effectiveness state.
In addition to the Survey on Automation and
Effectiveness, the present Study also lays stress on continuous improvement.
The study therefore offers a ‘’Library Audit Checklist’. Compliance to the
eleven criteria as mentioned therein for library operations shall add continuous
value to the Library effectiveness.
Further, the study also offers software that enables MIS implementation
through the use of an integrated database. The proposed software
provides solution to all limitations of the conventional library management
systems. Figure exhibits the decision
flow used in the present software using integrated database comprising
Membership Data, Bibliographic Data, Circulation Data and the Maintenance Data. The highlighted area in figure reveals the
benefits that the execution of proposed MIS enabling software offers against
the Conventional library system.
Availability
checks, a purpose that was served by card catalogues in the conventional system
can now be solved through electronic data with a value added output.
Among the other
benefits of integrated database are vendor data management, classification,
cataloguing, fine calculation, no-dues certificate, sending reminders to
readers for delay in return, and timely system generated alarms for library
maintenance.
Audit
Checklist
|
(1) |
Budgetary Allocation |
a) Automation |
i)
Academic |
|
ii) Circulation |
|||
|
iii) Vigilance |
|||
|
b)
bibliographic Resource |
i)
Acquisition (Print and Electronic) |
||
|
ii) Maintenance |
|||
|
c) Infrastructure |
i) Furniture, Fittings and Fixtures |
||
|
ii) Lighting and Ventilation |
|||
|
iii)
Building Expansion, |
|||
|
iv)
Repairs and Maintenance |
|||
|
(2) |
Cost Effectiveness |
a)
Operational Cost |
|
|
|
|
b)
Cost Benefit Ratio (use) |
|
|
(3) |
Income Substitution |
a) Self Financing |
|
|
b) External Funds (Grants and Aids) |
|||
|
(4) |
Staff |
||
|
(5) |
Training |
a) Staff |
|
|
b) Readers |
|||
|
c) Awareness (Display Of Rules) |
|||
|
(6) |
Services |
a) Reader Satisfaction – Accessibility |
|
|
|
|
b) Reader Satisfaction - Response Time |
|
|
(7) |
Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) |
a) Availability Index |
|
|
b) Performance Index |
|||
|
c) Quality Index |
|||
|
(8) |
Readership and Circulation |
||
|
(9) |
Maintenance |
||
|
(10) |
Continuous Improvement |
a) Feedback and Suggestion Mechanism |
|
|
|
|
b) Replicating Best Practices |
|
Proposed Software for Management Information Systems in Libraries
In the light of
above discussion; the general conclusions drawn and key lessons to be learned
through this study are:
·
MIS is possible – but only with dedicated staff
resources.
·
MIS Enables Executive Support
·
Education and Training are Vital
·
Openness and Trust must be built for Feedback and
Continuous Improvement
·
Collaboration between system staff and other
stakeholders
·
Information Flow
·
Skill sets - continuous training on new tools
·
Flexibility - Innovation encouraged
·
Involve staff at each step
·
Planning and Service Standards
·
When possible start with a mature integrated system
for Synergic Effects.
Further, to enable
MIS successfully in libraries, following eight principles are recommended for
realisation of library objectives
Principle 1 - customer focus
Principle 2 – leadership
Principle 3 - involvement of people
Principle 4 - process approach
Principle 5 - system approach to management
Principle 6 - continual improvement
Principle 7 - factual approach to decision making
Principle 8 - mutually beneficial relationship
OBSTACLES TO EFFECTIVE, EFFICIENT USE OF MIS
IN LIBRARIES
·
The crude form of data provided by most ILS
·
A general lack of agreement about what data are most
useful for management purposes
·
A general lack of expertise in interpreting data
·
The perceived high cost of deploying MIS
·
The frequent absence or underutilization of MIS in
the parent organizations of many libraries
·
A general sense that MIS devalues the less easily
measured aspects of information storage and retrieval and/or the human art of
management
·
Some MIS may not distinguish easily and well between
different levels of management within a library and various types of management
activities
·
Interoperability problems between data sets hinder
efficient access
Libraries have to adapt to changing user
requirements and expectations. Web 2.0 technologies can provide very useful
tools in this transformation.
It is now an
established fact that MIS in library and information sciences through
automation has become inevitable. The environments in which libraries operate are under the constant
pressure of change. Libraries have to create environments that enable
successful assessment and the implementation of results based on these
assessments. Considering the above requirements, the
present study attempted to make the library operations measurable, improvable
and thus effective. The survey of readers on Library Automation and Library
Effectiveness provided feedback on their perceptions and expectations. The
present Study also lays stress on continuous improvement. The study therefore
offers a ‘’Library Audit Checklist’ (See Annexure 2). Compliance to the eleven criteria as
mentioned therein for library operations shall add continuous value to the
Library effectiveness. Further, the study also offers software that enables MIS implementation
through the use of an integrated database. The proposed software
provides solution to all limitations of the conventional library management
systems through effective decision making by the use of integrated database
comprising Membership Data, Bibliographic Data, Circulation Data and the
Maintenance Data (See Annexure 1).
India is marching ahead fast, introduction
of INFLIBNET, OPAC are our success stories. With the launch of EDU-SAT and
ANUSAT (Micro Satellite) a new chapter in the area of information sciences in
education has begun. Libraries have to adapt to changing user requirements and
expectations. Web 2.0 technologies can provide very useful tools in this
transformation.
My study proposes Libraries of Chhattisgarh
to be a benchmark for automation and effectiveness of libraries in India. My
direction and efforts are validated, in line to the present study; NKC proposes
the creation of a model Library Charter, a list of services to be performed by
libraries, a Library Network and a National Repository for Bibliographic
Records. NKC also recommends for catalogues of all libraries to be put on local
state and national website with necessary linkages. This will enable networking
of different types of libraries and setting up of a National Repository of
Bibliographic Records and a centralized collaborative virtual enquiry-handling
system using the latest ICT.
REFERENCES:
1. ADEOTI-ADEKEYE
(W B). Importance of management information system. Library Reviews. 46, 5/6;
1997, p.318-327.
2. BRAISBY
(P S), MENZIES (J I ) and WAGHORN (C
A). Development of management
information system for academic libraries. London. British Library. 1987, p.
45.
3. BROPHY
(P). Management information and decision
support system in libraries. Aldershot: Gower. 1987, p. 119-129.
4. CULLEN
(R). A model of a management information system for library and information
service managers. International Journal
of Information and Library Research. 2,
1; 1990, p. 23-24.
5. FERGUSON
(S) and WHITELAW (M). Computerized management information system in libraries.
Australian Libraries Journal. 41; 1942, p. 184-198.
6. FULWEILER
(Rebecca D). Role of management information systems. Journal of Academic Librarianship. 27, 5;
September 2001, p. 386-390.
7. KURUPPU
(D C). Academic libraries and management information system in Sri Lanka. Focus on International and Comparative
Librarianship. 33, 1; 2002, p. 5-14.
8. LAKOS
(Amos). Library management information in the client server environment: A
proposed new model. Proceedings of the 2nd Northumbria
International conference on Performance Measurement in Libraries and
Information Services, Newcastle upon Tyne: Department of Information and
Library Management, University if Northumbria. 1998,
p. 277-286.
9. LANCASTER (FW). If you want to evaluate
your library London Library Association. 1988.
10. McCLURE (Charles
R). Information for academic library decision making: The case for organizational information
management. Westport, CO.: Green wood.
1980.
11. OLORUNSOLA (R). Management information
systems in Nigerian universities. Aslibs Proceedings. 49, 5; May 1997, p. 113-116.
Webography
1.
http://personal.anderson.ucla.edu/amos.lakos/mis/misbibnew.pdf
2.
http://library.uwaterloo.ca/~aalakos/misbib97.html
3.
http://www.arl.org/stats/newmeans/emetries/contract00-01.html
4.
http://www.lib.washington.edu/assessment/
5.
http://www.lib.virginia.edu/mis
6.
http://www.lib.virginia.edu/bsc
7.
http://libqual.org/documents/admin/vpohillerseff.pdf
8.
http://www.cordis.lu/libraries/en/projects/decide.html
9.
http://www.cordis.europa.eu/libraries/en/projects/minstrel.html
10.
http://www.cordis.lu/libraries/en/projects/decimal.html
11.
http://www.ii.fsu.edu/~cmcclure/
12.
http://www.dcu.ie/library/eqlipse/
13.
http://www.docdeliveryhaworthpress.com
14.
http://www.shef.ac.uk./~is/publications/hodsin/index.html
15. http://biblio.syr.edu/bibliomining/articles/nicholson1.doc
Received on 03.11.2009 Accepted on 18.11.2010
©A&V
Publications all right reserved
Asian J. Management 1(2): Oct. – Dec. 2010 page 39-46