A study to analyze the discrete use of fear appeal
by advertisers in Indian advertisements and their impact on viewers
Dr.
Ashok Kumar Mishra
Associate Professor and Head,
Dept. of Commerce, St. Thomas College, Bhilai
*Corresponding Author E-mail: ashok.mishra261@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
A fear appeal
posits the risks of using and not using a specific product, service, or idea
such that if you don’t “buy,” some particular dire consequences will occur.
That is, fear appeals rely on a threat to an individual’s well-being that
motivates him or her toward action, e.g. increasing control over a situation or
preventing an unwanted outcome. However, the scope of fear appeal is not
limited in using it alone. It has been observed that fear appeal is used
subliminally along with other appeals playing the lead role in various
advertisement
The purpose of
this paper is to review and examine the fear appeal hidden in various advertisements
which are classified under different appeals such as Humour,
Patriotism, self esteem etc and their impact on purchase behaviour
of the viewers. In particular, this
paper includes the following sections: introduction, definition of a fear appeal,
study of a few advertisements showing subliminal use of fear appeals, and
summary.
KEYWORDS:
The most basic of human needs is the need for
food, clothing and shelter. Special need for these necessities cannot be
created with advertising. However there are certain other products that provide
comfort in life and advertising aims to generate demand for these products.
Advertising uses appeals as a way of persuading people to buy certain products.
Advertising appeals are designed in a way so as to create a positive image of
the individuals who use certain products. Advertising agencies and companies
use different types of advertising appeals to influence the purchasing
decisions of people. The most important types of advertising appeals include
emotional and rational appeals. Emotional appeals are often effective for the
youth while rational appeals work well for products directed towards the older
generation.
·
Emotional
Appeals:
An emotional appeal is related
to an individual’s psychological and social needs for purchasing certain
products and services. Many consumers are emotionally motivated or driven to
make certain purchases. Advertisers aim to cash in on the emotional appeal and
this works particularly well where there is not much difference between
multiple product brands and its offerings. Emotional appeal includes personal
and social aspects.
·
Personal Appeal
Some personal emotions that can
drive individuals to purchase products include safety, fear, love, humor, joy,
happiness, sentiment, stimulation, pride, self esteem, pleasure, comfort,
ambition, nostalgia etc.
1.
2. Social Appeal
3. Social factors cause people to make
purchases and include such aspects as recognition, respect, involvement,
affiliation, rejection, acceptance, status and approval.
4.
5. Fear Appeal
6. Fear is also an important factor
that can have incredible influence on individuals. Fear is often used to good
effect in advertising and marketing campaigns of beauty and health products
including insurance. Advertising experts indicate that using moderate levels of
fear in advertising can prove to be effective.
Humor Appeal
Humor is an element that is used
in around 30% of the advertisements. Humor can be an excellent tool to catch
the viewer’s attention and help in achieving instant recall which can work well
for the sale of the product. Humor can be used effectively when it is related
to some benefit that the customer can derive without which the joke might
overpower the message.
In advertising, a fear appraisal, or fear appeal,
uses consumers' fears to motivate them to purchase a product or contribute to a
cause. The consumer appraises the product in light of their fear of the
consequences of not buying. For example, an ad campaign may appeal to people's
fear of body odour to convince them to buy deodorant.
Consumers who are afraid of sweat stains or odours
are more likely to respond and buy the deodorant. Fear appeals can be used in
convincing people to appraise and change their behaviour,
such as quitting smoking or not drinking and driving. Some behaviour-change
ads may feature photos of corpses or very strong wording, such as the
anti-smoking ads showing terminal cancer patients and stating "Smoking
Kills." These types of behavioural appraisal ads
are also used in the non-profit sector, encouraging people to help save the
environment or help eliminate poverty by giving money to charities. The ads
encourage consumers to appraise and change their behaviour
regarding charitable giving. Some fear appraisal ads focus on less well-defined
fears, such as ads for plastic surgery or skin creams that focus on consumers'
fears of looking old.
Fear appeals (sometimes called threat
appeals) can be defined in terms of their content, or by the reaction they
engender from the audience (O'Keefe, 1990). For example, fear appeals usually
contain "gruesome content" in the form of vivid language (e.g.
"thick purulent, choking secretions welled into the tracheotomy
wound," Leventhal, 1965), personalistic
language (e.g., "smokers like you ..."), or gory pictures (e.g.,
photographs of crash victims). Alternatively, fear appeals have been defined in
terms of the amount of fear aroused and/or experienced by the audience (i.e.,
physiologically or psychologically). Reported or aroused fear is usually
evaluated by a manipulation check, with a high fear appeal yielding
significantly greater levels of reported or aroused fear than a low fear
appeal.
Definition of
Fear Appeal
“A fear appeal is a persuasive message that
attempts to arouse fear in order to divert behavior through the threat of
impending danger or harm.” A fear appeal presents a risk, presents the
vulnerability to the risk, and then describes a suggested form of protective
action”
“Advertising that attempts to create anxiety in
the consumer on the basis of fear, so that the consumer is encouraged to
resolve this fear by purchasing the product or service.”
An
appeal is the motive to which an advertisement is directed. Its purpose is to
move the audience toward a goal set by the advertiser. Fear appeals are
commonly used in many types of marketing communications, e.g., the marketing of
products, services, social causes, and ideas. The basic message is “if you
don’t do this (buy, vote, believe, support, learn, etc.), some particular dire
consequences will occur” (Glascoff, 2000, 35). That
is, advertisers invoke fear by identifying the negative results of not using
the product or the negative results of engaging in unsafe behaviour.
In general, however, fear appeals are effective in increasing ad interest,
involvement, recall, and persuasiveness (LaTour,
Snipes, and Bliss, 1996). “Fear appeals are one of the most frequently used
motivators to get people to help themselves” (Bagozzi
and Moore, 1994, 56). In fact, fear appeals have grown in popularity because
advertisers have found them to increase ad interest and persuasiveness (LaTour, Snipes, and Bliss, 1996). Evidence also suggests
that individuals “better remember and more frequently recall ads that portray
fear than they do warm or upbeat ads or ads with no emotional content” (Snipes,
LaTour, and Bliss, 1999, 273).
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY:
Primary
Data was collected by showing advertisements to the viewers and collecting
their responses through directed personal interview.
Sample:
A
sample was collected through cluster sampling method of 30 viewers from
different socio economic groups. Their discriptions
are as follows:
·
5
students, Male, age 18-23
·
5
students, Female, age 18-23
·
5
Government employees, Male, age 35-45
·
5
Private sector employees, Female, age
30-40
·
5
Businessmen, Male, age 40-50
·
5
Housewives, Female age 35-45
METHODOLOGY:
Primary
data was collected by showing each group 5 various types advertisements out of
which 3 advertisements are classified in Humour
appeal and Social appeal whereas remaining 2 advertisements are of purely Fear
appeal.
Each
group was shown all the 5 advertisements separately and then a directed
personal interview was conducted and the questions were asked regarding the
advertisements they were shown earlier.
Their
responses were recorded and analyzes on the basis of the appeals. i.e the responses related to both fear appeal advertisements
and other advertisements using discrete fear appeal were compared and the
effectiveness of both the classifications were ascertained.
Advertisements:
Advertised Brand |
Appeal Used in that Advertisement |
Glycodine |
Humour |
The Hindu |
Social Awareness |
M-Seal |
Humour |
ICICI Prudential |
Fear |
Anti-Smoking
Campaign |
Fear |
Questions for Interview
Q1:
Did you like that advertisement? (Mentioning the specific brand) Yes/No
This
question was asked to see if the advertiser had succeeded to connect with the
viewer or not.
Q2:
Which
type of advertisement was it? Humourous/ Awaking /
Fearful/ None
This
question was asked to analyze whether the viewer is able to understand the tone
of message or not.
Q3: Did
you notice any kind of hidden threat in this advertisement? Yes/No
This
question was asked only for the advertisements in which Fear appeal was not
used directly.
Q4: What
according to you was the threat?
This
was an Open-Ended question only asked if the respondent responded positively
for the 3rd question to know if the viewer is recognizing the hidden
threat.
Q5:
Can this element of threat be an important factor in making your purchasing
decision for that brand? Yes/No
This
question was asked to all the respondents to see whether both the fear appeal
and non-fear appeal advertisements has similar kind of effect.
Findings:
These
are the findings which are calculated and tabulated on the basis of the
viewers’ responses regarding each advertisement
Advertisement: Glycodine:
This
is a funny advertisement which shows how coughing at a wrong moment can cause
troubles. The responses were as follows:
Advertisement: The Hindu
This
advertisement portrays the dreadful condition of youth’s knowledge about Indian
constitution and heritage. The responses were as follows:
Advertisement: M-Seal
This
Funny advertisement shows how even a droplet of water dripping unwontedly can
change your life in an unfortunate way. The responses were as follows:
It was clearly
seen that the respondents were able to recognize the hidden threat when asked.
They also stated that they always used to skip this point but are surely able
to recognize the threat after giving it some thought. A substantial percent of respondents think
that this hidden threat plays an important role in their buying behaviour.
CONCLUSION:
The study gave
enough indications that not only advertisers are using fear appeal as their
strategic tool in direct representation of fear, but as well as indirect
interpretation of fear also. This study also shows that the viewers have a good
understanding of what they are watching and what the marketer is trying to show
them. The respondents show that the hidden fear appeal might not visible
normally, but surely seen if observed the advertisement properly and also if
they give it some though. Though the direct use of Fear appeal surely creates
an impact on the viewer, the discrete use of this appeal can also creates a
substantial effect on the viewer and become 1 of the important factor in
viewer’s purchase decision regarding that specific brand whose advertisement
uses the fear appeal in one or the other way.
This study tried
to show that even if the advertisement is not of the genre Fear, but if the
fear appeal is used tactfully, it can create an impact on the viewer’s mind and
can play an important factor in decision making.
REFERENCES:
Fear appeal theory, Kaylene C. Williams California State University,
Stanislaus
Barron's Educational Series, c 2000, 1994, 1987
Fear
appeals and persuasion: a review and update of the extended parallel process
model Erin K. Maloney, Maria K. Lapinski and Kim
Witte
Websites
www.youtube.com
www.wikipedia.com
www.allbusiness.com
Received on 27.01.2014 Modified on 05.02.2014
Accepted on 12.02.2014 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Management 5(2):
April-June, 2014 page 272-276