Role of
Advertisement in Brand Attitude and Consumer Decision Making
Dr. Ramesh Kumar Chaturvedi
Assistant Professor, Department of Management Studies,
Gurughasidas University (A Central Government University), Bilaspur,
CG
*Corresponding Author E-mail: drrameshchaturvedi1@gmail.com
Idea:
Advertisement is
known to develop consumer attitudes towards products and services portrayed in
message. Are marketers really engaging consumers to act favorably through
branding done by advertising or consumers simply enjoy marketing communication
and respond with inaction? Relation of Cognition, Affect and Behavior (CAB)
with Advertising is explored in this paper. Issues pertaining to effectiveness
of advertising are much discussed among industry and academicians alike.
Ability of advertisement to build brand attitude then to translate brand
attitude into purchase (behavior) and finally bring permanency in behavior
though entrenched, strong and favorable consumer attitude is focal point of
this research.
Scope:
Effectiveness of
advertising has always a matter of interest to marketers. This paper deals with
finding what consumers think about an advertisement and up to what extent an
advertisement engages consumer exposed to advertisement. Influence of
advertising on purchase decision is also examined. The data is collected over a
period of three months through structure questionnaire. Suitable constructs are
used to capture underlying attitudes and perception of consumers.
Importance:
Knowing the role
of advertisement in demand creation is a profound tool in hands of marketing
communication planners. Through insight offered by the research, marketers
could priorities their advertising budgets and stimulate the demand for the
brands they manage.
KEYWORDS: Branding,
Consumer decision making, Advertising, Brand Attitude
INTRODUCTION:
Companies spend heavily on brand building
through well-orchestrated marketing communication programs in line with their
organizational vision. Advertising is
appreciated as well as criticized by stake holder for benefits it brings and
cost burden it puts on the firm. Marketing people and more particularly
advertising department is continuously under pressure to justify their budget.
The return on investment in advertising is usually long term and somewhat
intangible. Under such circumstances it is important to study and put forward
the differential effect that advertising has in revenue generation through the
brand being advertised.
Since branding is painfully time consuming
and expensive activity, so it is imperative to assess the importance of
advertising, not only for creating awareness but also for its ability to
actually engage consumers and favorably influence purchase decisions. A brand’s
messages are received through series of filters that exists with
in each consumer’s life. What settles into his/her brain is the only
true image the brand has created. The rest are only intentions & wasted
messages and may have no role to play in consumer decision making. This
research intends to examine the effect that advertising has on consumers brand
attitude and role of brand attitude on purchase decisions. Further an effort is
made to analyze the consumer’s attitude towards buying branded products.
LITERATURE REVIEW:
Sengupta, (1990) has established that:
as the world has entered into the third millennium, the national and
international environment is surcharged with an all-round consumer
hyperactivity, posing new challenges for the marketers. The last century
witnessed many innovations, new concepts and techniques in the field of
marketing. Inspired by the outstanding success of many Japanese companies,
several national and multinational companies are spending huge amount of money
in improving quality and in implementing the total quality management concept (Lambert, 1992). Chaturvedi
(2003) reported that
Indian shoppers seek emotional value more than the functional value of shopping
and group pressure and WOM operates more apparently than advertised message.
Their shopping at organized retails is based more on the entertainment value
associated with malls than on the functional value of products communicated in
advertisements. The marketers need to address the brand attitude formation
process of both type of consumers, those who depend more on formal marketing
communication and others who rely on informal and personal sources to frame
their consumption related attitudes (Chatterje & Chaturvedi, 2012). Research suggests that perception of
consumers towards advertising and its influence on purchase decision in general
is changing and more studies are required to unearth the advertisement– brand
attitude formation relationship (Paul, 2002; Lichtenstein, 1983). There are
many brand/branding definitions and descriptions that focus on the methods used
to achieve differentiation and to emphasize the benefits the consumers derive
from purchasing brands through favorable brand attitude formation. There is a
general agreement in the marketing literature that the brand is more than a
name given to a product. It embodies a whole set of physical, social and
psychological attributes and beliefs to consumers (Kotler,
1997; Schiffman et. al., 2010; Panda, 2004; Johri, 2007). A brand may
mean different things to different consumers. While brand management may strive
to communicate through marketing communication and advertisements a specific
and consistent image to the market, consumers may develop different perceptions
that underpin their brand attitude and purchase intentions of the brand (Rao, 1989, Parashuraman, 2008; Sengupta,
1990). There is need of research to
advised and acknowledge the relationship between knowledge, attitude and
behavior of consumers.
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY:
An effort has been made to analyze the impact
of advertising on Brand awareness and consumer behavior, regarding purchases of
branded products in major cities of Chhattisgarh. The objectives could be
stated as follows:
1. To study the impact of
advertisement on building favorable brand attitude.
2. Influence of advertisement
message on purchase decision.
3. Attitude of consumers towards
buying branded products.
METHODOLOGY AND DESIGN OF STUDY:
The study was performed in Bilaspur, Raigarh, Korba and Raipur in a period of two months during May and
June 2014. A sample size of 200 is used for data collection through structured
questionnaire. The sampling technique is Judgment and convenience sampling. The
respondents were requested to fill the questionnaire at public places such as
railway stations, bus stop, leisure visitors at Malls etc where they were
waiting for one thing or other and they had ample time that they wanted to
pass. The extent of Participation was appreciatable
at such places. 50 questionnaires were filled at each city. Design of the
research is descriptive and explanatory (Cooper and Schindler, 2009).
Suitable hypothesis is stated to test the
‘impact of advertisement on building brand attitude’. Five item construct is
developed and used to study the respondents perception towards ‘impact of advertisement
on building brand attitude (IABA)’. The consumer’s responses were measured
on five point Likert’s summated scale. The items of
the construct are as follows:
Construct 1
1. Brands that are advertised
usually deliver better vale and are more beneficial.
2. I believe brands that are
endorsed by celebrities as trustable.
3. Advertised brands offer better
performance.
4. I talk favorably about the
brands seen in advertisements.
5. Products that advertised are
usually of better quality.
6. I switch to an unknown brand
with similar packaging if priced lower.
Internal consistency alpha was 0.72 for
this construct that is suitable conducting research in behavioral sciences (Nurnaly, 1997). The hypothesis is tested by analyzing the
variance among the attitude of respondent collected through construct 1. If
that there is no significant variance in attitude of consumers and variable
‘IABA’ has high mean value and we can safely infer that consumers perceive that
brand attitude is positively influenced by advertising. In case there is
significant difference in perception of consumers collected through construct
1, then further Posthoc analysis has to be done to
study inter group variations in perception of consumers and identify factors
that underpin the difference. Difference in brand attitude based on advertising
is analyzed among various age groups and genders.
In the present study, second hypothesis is
stated based on second objective to test the impact of advertising on purchase
decision for branded products in major cities Chhattisgarh. To test the
hypothesis about the ‘influence of advertisement on purchase decisions’
(the variable is named as ‘IAPD’) a one way ANOVA is conducted between two
groups (two levels of a categorical variable) one who has purchased an advertised
product and other ‘not purchased’ an advertised product in recent past mediated
by their perception about influence of advertisement on purchase decisions
(IAPD). Respondents were asked to mention whether they had made any recent
purchase of advertised product or not. Then through seven items construct
scaled on five point Likert scale influence of
advertisement on their purchase decisions (IAPD) is captured. The items of
construct are as follows:
Construct 2
1. While shopping and evaluating
products to purchase, advertisements that I had seen surface in my mind.
2. My decision to make a purchase
of branded product is influenced by advertisements.
3. Television commercial influences
my brand choice.
4. While making a purchase decision
I prefer that brand among brands on display which I have seen in
advertisements.
5. While buying across the counter
(Kirana stores) I tell the brand name to salesperson
based on my memory of advertisements.
6. On seeing the advertisements
post purchase I feel good about my purchase decision.
7. I choose brands as suggested by
sales people.
The third objective is to study the Tendency
of consumers to buy branded products and the variable is named as
TCBBP. Five items construct (Construct 3
given below) with internal consistency 0.68 is developed and used to
collect consumer’s tendency with respect to this variable.
Construct 3
1. Known brands usually boost my
purchase confidence.
2. Family or friends appreciate
when I buy branded products.
3. It is matter of prestige buying
and using branded products.
4. I don’t need reference while
buying branded products.
5. I take quick buying decisions
for branded products.
The analysis was also done gender wise and hypothesized as both
the genders do not differ in their attitudes towards branded products. A
correlation analysis between variables IABA and TCBBP is used to validate the
influence advertisement on building brand attitude. This test is based on
premise that those respondent (consumers) having high scores on influence of
advertising on brand attitude must also have high score on tendency towards
buying advertised branded product. In case the value of correlation coefficient
is positive and high one could infer that those consumers who build favorable
brand attitude based on advertising also have tendency to buy such (branded)
products. A low correlation coefficient value in turn implies that brand
attitudes build through advertisement do not translate into purchase tendency
of branded products. Since a strong attitude translates into behavior, a low
correlation coefficient value will imply that advertisement doesn’t causes
strong and permanent attitude towards branded products in general and hence
influence of advertising on brand attitude is temporary and specific to brands
being advertised leading to infer that to maintain the effect of advertisement
on ‘brand purchase’ regular and continuous advertising is required.
Finally a three variable regression analysis test with IABA and
IABP as independent and TCBBP as dependent variable is used to see systematic
effect of Cognition (C) and Behavior (B) leading to
Retained Attitude (RA) towards branded products
that underpins the consumer tendency to buy branded products (C X
B --> RA). This is called CBRA (may be pronounced as “k'abra”) framework for brand attitude based
on advertising.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
1. Statement of Hypothesis based on
First objective:
H10: ‘Advertisement
has no impact of on building consumer brand attitude”
H1a: “Advertisement
has significant impact of on building consumer brand attitude”
The hypothesis is tested by
analyzing the variance among the attitude of respondent collected through
construct 1. ANOVA test (‘p’= 0.02) shows that there is no significant variance
in attitude of consumers and we reject H10. Variable ‘IABA’ has high
mean value (Cumulative average IABA=3.9) so we can safely infer that consumers
perceive that brand attitude is positively influenced by advertising.
2. Statement of Hypothesis and
analysis based on second objective:
Ho: Purchase decision of branded
products is independent of Advertisement.
H1: Advertisement does influence
the purchase decision of branded products.
Analysis
of the Relationship between Impact of
advertisements and brand awareness
is again done through one way ANOVA test with two levels of independent variable
(1=purchased branded product recently and 2= not purchased branded product
recently) and dependent variable IAPD, reflecting perception of influence of
advertisement on purchase decision captured through construct 2 as mentioned
above. The p=0.021 shows the two groups do not differ significantly in their
perception towards influence of advertisement on purchase decision and we
reject Ho, Null hypothesis.
Therefore we infer that advertising indifferently influence all buyers to
purchase advertised branded product.
3.
Correlation coefficient between TCBBP
and IABA ‘r’ = 0.78 is significantly high. This finding allows inferring that
those consumers having high values on perception that advertising influences
brand attitude they also tend to buy branded product. So it can be concluded
that advertising not only build favorable brand attitude but also play
important role in translating this attitude in purchase of branded products.
4.
The mean value of TCBBP for male and
female respondents do not differ significantly (‘p’=0.027) when tested through
ANOVA at 0.05 level of significance. Hence it is concluded that influence of
advertisement on both genders for buying advertised branded products is
similar.
5.
A
regression analysis between IABA, IAPD as independent variable and TCBBP as
dependent variable derives r-square as 0.118 (where, R = 0.343, constant=0.356,
b1=0.209 and b2=0.190) significant at 10% Level of
Significance with collinearity values (Tolerance and
VIF) within limit. Though the variance in TCBBP explained by independent
variables is about 12% but relation is significant and can’t be ignored.
Model:
TCBBP
= 0.356 + 0.209IABA + 0.190IAPD
On the
basis of this finding it can be concluded that consumers who develop positive
brand attitude under influence of advertisement and consumers who purchase
advertised products develop general tendency to buy advertised products even if
they have not encountered an advertisement recently.
CONCLUSION
AND SUGGESTION:
Advertising
indifferently influence all buyers to purchase advertised branded product.
Findings of this research indicate that advertising builds favorable attitude
toward the brand advertised. It is also found that consumers favorable attitude
influences purchase decision made by them and this attitude in general has
profound effect on consumer’s tendency to buy advertised product repeatedly.
The findings suggest that scope of advertising is broad and may have delayed
impact on consumer’s intentions to buy branded product. The influence of
advertising has lasting effect on buying branded product such that it builds a
‘pro-branded psychology’ among consumers that extends beyond the advertised
product that consumer has been exposed recently to other products that has
notion of ‘Brand’ in mind of buyer due to some old reference but may not been
exposed in recent past. This article suggests that marketers should keep using
advertising for building strong and favorable consumer attitude towards brand.
Advertising is also found stimulating purchase decision and ultimately
contributing towards revenue generation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
I am deeply indebted to Prof. L.P. Pateriya, Dean and Head, Department of Management Studies, Gurughasidas University, for his support, specifically in
data analysis. I also thank to the students of this department for supporting
the data collection and tabulation.
REFERENCES:
1)
Chaturvedi Mukesh. Buying Research. Wheeler Publishing. New Delhi.
2002.
2)
Chatterje A. and
Chaturvedi K. Ramesh.
Fundamentals of Marketing – A Contemporary Approach. New Royle
Publishing Company. Lucknow. 2012.
3)
Johri Shweta. Brand Management. Galgotia
Publishing Company. New Delhi. 2007.
4)
Kotler
Phillip. Marketing management, Analysis, planning and implementation, control.
Prentice Hall of India Pvt. Ltd. New Delhi. 1997. 9th ed.
5)
Lambert Zarrel.
Price and choice Behavior. Journal of Marketing Research. Vol.29(3); 1992:
201-208.
6)
Lichtenstein Donald R. et.al. Price
Perception and consumer shopping Behavior. A field study Journal of Marketing
Research. Vol.30(2); 1993: 123-129.
7)
Panda Tapan K.
Building brands in the Indian Market. Excel Books, New Delhi. 2004.
8)
Parashuraman A. and
Kumar Ambarish K. Impact of price and Brand on
consumer’s choice - An experimental study, in Subhash
C. Mehta. Indian consumer studies and cases for marketing decisions. Tata Mc.Grow hill publishing Co. Ltd.; New Delhi. 2008.
9)
Rao Akshay R. and Monroe Kent B. The effects of price, brand
name and store name on buyer’s perception of product reality - An Integrative
Review. Journal of Marketing Research. Vol.26(9); 1989: 234-240
10)
Schiffman Leon
G., Kanuk Leslie Lazar and Kumar Ramesh.
Consumer Behavior. Pearson Education by Kindersley Dorling. New Delhi. 2010. 10th
ed.
11)
Sengupta Subrota. Brand Positioning. Tata McGraw Hill Co. Ltd., New
Delhi. 1990.
ANNEXURE 1:
Questionnaire
(This questionnaire is part of
Academic activity; data will be used purely for academic research. Your
cooperation is solicited)
Filter Question:
1. Do you regularly buy
products, Goods and Services for your personal or family use? Yes_____
No_______
2. Have you recently purchased a
product after watching an advertisement? Yes_____ No_______
3. Is it worth buying branded
products? Yes_____ No_______
A. Effect of advertising on
consumer’s brand attitude.
Brands that are advertised
usually deliver better vale and are more beneficial. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
I believe brands that are
endorsed by celebrities as trustable. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
Advertised brands offer better
performance. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
I talk favorably about the
brands seen in advertisements. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
Products that advertised are
usually of better quality. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
B. Influence of Advertisement on buying
branded products.
While shopping and evaluating
products to purchase, advertisements that I had seen surface in my mind. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
My decision to make a purchase
of branded product is influenced by advertisements. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
Television commercial influences
my brand choice. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
While making a purchase decision
I prefer that brand among brands on display which I have seen in
advertisements. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
While buying across the counter
(Kirana stores) I tell the brand name to
salesperson based on my memory of advertisements. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
On seeing the advertisements
post purchase I feel good about my purchase decision. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
I choose brands as suggested by
sales people. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
C. Attitude of consumers towards buying branded products
Known brands usually boost my
purchase confidence. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
Family or friends appreciate
when I buy branded products. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
It is matter of prestige buying
and using branded products. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
I don’t need reference while
buying branded products. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
I take quick buying decisions
for branded products. |
Strongly Agree (5)_____(4)_____(3)______(2)______(1) Strongly Disagree |
Age:__________ Highest
Education:_________ Gender:__________
Received on 05.09.2014 Modified on 10.09.2014
Accepted on 28.09.2014 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Management 5(4): Oct.-
Dec., 2014 page 415-419